MR MACKINLAY, WHAT HAVE YOU DONE?

craig-mackinlay

Craig Mackinlay, one of the founders of UKIP, is now the Conservative MP of Thanet South in Kent.

He has recently published a letter attacking a number of his own constituents as being “anti-Semitic”.

He should not have done this.

But having done this, he should consider the following…

Someone who deplores what Israel is doing in Palestine – including its 50-year long illegal occupation , with illegal settlements, ongoing oppression and a thorough-going disregard of human rights and other acts declared illegal by the United Nations – is NOT being anti-Semitic.

Someone who is angered by the way a minority of Israel’s supporters try to excuse the country’s crimes by shamefully exploiting the horrific suffering of the Jewish people in World War II is NOT being anti-Semitic.

Remember, too, Mr Mackinlay, that when a person is writing about a controversial subject or discussing that subject with other people on social media it is comparatively easy to isolate their quotes in a way that unfairly represents their real views.

And for that reason, before publishing serious allegations about anyone – let alone your own constituents who you are supposed to serve – you should, as an absolute minimum, give them a chance to respond.

How is anyone possibly going to ask for your help as their MP when you have identified, attacked and branded them in public?

Finally, perhaps most importantly, you need to consider carefully what a true anti-Semite is – someone who attacks Jewish people for being Jewish and believes they do bad things because they are Jewish. This is the most despicable racism and everyone should condemn it without reservation.

Mr Mackinlay, please consider all this, retract your allegations and apologise unreservedly to the people you have attacked.

 

Advertisements

3 comments

  1. Thank you
    I have been heartbroken to find myself accused of being an Antisemite, ( without any chance to rebut) Mr McKinley made these public accusations without the decency of informing me of his accusations, he has judged, juried and sentenced me, (and Women doing amazing work to stand up for victims, fighting racism in all its forms). My health has broken down from the stress of these public accusations. I feel incredibly unsafe, as i have seen some responses to Mr Mckinleys diatribe, and it is frightening to me. This from my local MP who only a few days before he published his public smears had sent me a private message on facebook saying he respected my views

    1. I’ve been attacked in the same letter and it’s very disturbing. I know how you feel – Mackinlay is our MP and is prepared to lash out at us with no regard to the effect. Who do we turn to for help.

      1. Hi, yes I feel totally bereft. He has so much power, and is abusing his power and us. So upset and sorry for the danger he has put all of us in

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s